Newsletter: Pizza restaurant opens today, PB&J wings a must-try

Hey Dayton!

Welcome to our first, weekly Dayton Food & Dining Newsletter of the new year! I hope everyone had a fun time celebrating the holidays with friends and family. My fiancé and I went to Miami Valley Gaming in Lebanon on New Year’s Eve and unfortunately we did not win big. We ended up leaving a little earlier than expected and watched the ball drop from home. If you enjoy gambling, sports betting in Ohio kicked off Jan. 1. Read more about what to expect here.

As the holidays came to an end, I realized that I had absolutely no food in the fridge. If I hadn’t gone to the grocery, we would be eating PB&J sandwiches all week. Before going grocery shopping on Sunday, I came across a new recipe on Facebook for Cream Cheese Stuffed Peppers. I decided to get the ingredients and give it a try. They were absolutely perfect! I’m sharing the recipe below. I really enjoy easy dinner recipes that use a block of cream cheese. If you think you have a recipe that I would like, email me here.

Ingredients:

  • 3-4 halved bell peppers
  • 1 pound of ground beef (I used ground turkey)
  • chopped onion (I skipped out on this and added a can of corn)
  • garlic powder (I measured to my liking and added onion powder and crushed red pepper)
  • 1 block of cream cheese
  • 1 can of rotel

Directions: Pre-heat oven to 350 degrees. Place the halved peppers in the oven for approximately 5 minutes to soften before adding mixture. Brown meat and sauté onion in pan. Add seasonings. Add cream cheese and when softened add can of rotel (and corn). Add mixture to peppers and cook for 25 minutes. We added shredded cheese on top at the very end.


Mom’s PB&J boneless wings are a must-try

Bennett’s Publical is a family sports bar located at 67 S. Main Street in Miamisburg. NATALIE JONES/STAFF

icon to expand image

One of my goals for the New Year is to try out restaurants in the Dayton area that I have never been to before.

Over the weekend, I went to Bennett’s Publical, a family sports bar located at 67 S. Main St. in Miamisburg. I had the Walking Taco Salad and my fiancé had Mom’s PB&J Boneless Wings and Onion Straws.

Since it was our first time there, he was unsure of which sauce to get so the waiter was super nice and let us try the Mom’s PB&J, Trifecta and Honey Siracha sauces. The PB&J sauce is JIF peanut butter and mom’s triple pepper jelly secret recipe, according to the restaurant’s menu. I really enjoyed them and would probably get the PB&J or Trifecta boneless wings the next time. I also liked the breading on the Onion Straws and the Walking Taco Salad was exactly what I expected.

I have nothing but praise for my first experience at the sports bar. If you’re looking for a place to watch a football game, it’s the perfect place.


Old Scratch Pizza opens today in Beavercreek

Old Scratch Pizza is opening its third Dayton-area location at 4 p.m. on Wednesday, Jan. 4 in Beavercreek. FILE PHOTO

icon to expand image

Old Scratch Pizza is opening its third Dayton-area location at 4 p.m. today in Beavercreek.

The new restaurant is located at 2450 Dayton Xenia Road in the building that previously housed The Wellington Grille. The Wellington Grille’s last day of operation was June 21.

Similar to the restaurant’s first two locations in downtown Dayton and Centerville, Old Scratch Beavercreek features seating for 150 guests in a communal beer-hall style setting and a 16-seat bar, with 20 rotating taps of regional craft beers, a press release from Old Scratch said.

In addition, the new restaurant features an open kitchen allowing guests to watch the entire pizza making process from the dough being stretched to the pizza coming out of one of the three wood-fired ovens, the release said.

This location is very close to where I live. I’m looking forward to enjoying the patio after they remodel it in the spring.

Old Scratch has plans to open a fourth location in the former Troy Fire Department station located at 19 East Race St. in the heart of downtown. Expected opening is by early summer.


Elsa’s Mexican Restaurant may close

The shopping center with Elsa's Mexican Restaurant has been demolished on Far Hills Avenue.   TY GREENLEES / STAFF

icon to expand image

Now this was some hard news to swallow.

The Elsa’s Mexican Restaurant on Far Hills Avenue in Centerville will close if a pending business transaction is completed, and the Sheetz gas station, convenience store and restaurant chain would demolish the building and build a new store on the site.

Jason Hemmert, whose family has owned the local Elsa’s chain of restaurants for decades, told my colleague they are actively looking for a new location to continue “Elsa’s South” in the same vicinity.

There is no timeline for construction at this point, officials said.

“We would know months ahead of time, if in fact this deal goes through, when we would be closing,” Hemmert said of the Centerville site. “Everybody would have notice, and hopefully there might be another place ready by that time.”

Elsa’s currently has six locations — in Centerville, on Linden and Wilmington Avenues in Dayton, the Elsa’s Sports Grill in Kettering, and Elsa’s Cantinas in Sugarcreek Twp. and Springboro, which opened in 2018 and 2020.


Quick Bites:

🍽 Most-read food stories of 2022: From longtime restaurants being sold or closing to new restaurants opening, there’s been a lot of food news in 2022. Read more here.

🪓 Wild Axe Throwing expanding in Beavercreek: The entertainment venue has plans to expand this summer into the space next door to open a pinball bar. The expansion will include a bar remodel and kitchen addition.

🍩 Bill’s Donut Shop reopens: The donut shop closed Christmas Eve afternoon for their annual holiday hiatus. It reopened yesterday at 3 p.m.


Tell Us:

Thank you so much for reading my weekly newsletter! As the new year kicks off, I want to hear from you. Is there a new restaurant opening or are you wondering when an establishment is expected to open? Feel free to email me here and I’ll check it out.

Also, remember to follow Dayton Daily News on Facebook or search our Food & Dining section for the latest stories. I’ll have continuous updates on my Facebook or Twitter pages.

About the Author