The Butler County business was named the most charming restaurant in Ohio and a place to get “a memorable meal in a historic venue.”
>>NEW DETAILS: This Butler County café was named ‘most charming restaurant in Ohio’
That’s according to LoveFood.com, which doled out the honors to Cozy’s Café & Pub. The restaurant opened at 6440 Cincinnati-Dayton Road in Liberty Twp. in 2016, two years after owner Jan Collins opened Cozy’s Cottage.
>> 9 must-eat sandwiches in Dayton
The simply-not-simple grilled bologna is well worth the 30-minute-or-so drive from Dayton to the restaurant, which is located at 6440 Cincinnati Dayton Road in Butler County's Liberty Township.
>> You told us: 11 (more) sandwiches you must eat in Dayton
The sandwich is featured on the restaurant’s pub menu for $11 on the weekend brunch menu.
>> 8 things you've got to try at brunch at the Old Arcana
Jimi Gadd, the executive chef of Cozy's Cafe and Pub, said the sandwich starts with a great brioche bun from Sixteen Bricks Artisan Bakehouse bakery in Cincinnati.
“A sandwich always starts with the bread,” Gadd said. “You want something that is not going to get soggy on you.”
The bun is seared with butter on the restaurant’s flattop for mouthwatering results.
>> MORE: 9 must-eat sandwiches in Dayton
Cozy’s Cafe and Pub uses thin slices of a German bologna on the sandwich and elevated it with a thick slice of aged white cheddar and a whole grain mustard aioli-style sauce.
>> Unusual usual meat in upscale Oregon District diner's unbelievable sandwich
Crispy onion straws gives the sandwich much needed texture. It comes complete with fruit, salad or chips.
Cozy’s complex is impressive. Cozy’s Cottage opened in 2013 in a remodeled ranch house.
The chic and rustic pub and cafe opened in October of 2016 and has a patio.
The businesses are owned by Jan Collins, the owner of Putters Sports Grill restaurants.
>> Longtime restaurateur opens upscale eatery
Gadd said he and his team strive to offer the best brunch around.
>> 9 of the best brunch spots in Dayton
They are well on their way, with a menu that also includes a killer brunch charcuterie board ($21), fresh-cut breakfast potatoes, a Bloody Mary bar, country short rib biscuits ($13) and a chorizo focaccia sandwich that includes over-easy eggs, a charred avocado salsa and farmers cheese.
>> PHOTOS: Brunch at Cozy’s Cafe and Pub
>> The best Bloody Marys in Dayton
The restaurant is upscale, but not pretentious.
Close to closing during our visit, staff members sung along to music playing over the speakers ranging from Survivor’s “Eye of the Tiger” to the The Commodores’ "Oh No" as they cleared tables and delivered final meals.
So -- have we convinced you yet?
Want to go?
WHAT: Cozy's Cafe & Pub
WHEN: 4-9:30 p.m. Tuesday-Thursday, 4-10:30 p.m. Friday-Saturday. Brunch is served from 9 a.m.-2:30 p.m. Saturdays and 9 a.m.-4 p.m. on Sundays.
WHERE: 6440 Cincinnati Dayton Road, Liberty Twp., Ohio
INFO: cozyscafeandpub.com | Facebook | Instagram
About the Author