Carlisle man accused of damaging former church found not guilty by reason of insanity

A man is accused of breaking 125-year-old stained glass windows, other windows as well as furniture, equipment and other property inside a former church in the 3600 block of Wagner Ford Road in Harrison Twp. that was turned into two residences. CONTRIBUTED

Credit: Balduf, Jen (COP-Dayton)

Credit: Balduf, Jen (COP-Dayton)

A man is accused of breaking 125-year-old stained glass windows, other windows as well as furniture, equipment and other property inside a former church in the 3600 block of Wagner Ford Road in Harrison Twp. that was turned into two residences. CONTRIBUTED

A Carlisle man who was accused of causing major damage to a former church in Harrison Twp. has been found not guilty by reason of insanity.

Kurt Douglas Griggs, 45, was found not guilty by reason of insanity by Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Elizabeth Ellis, according to court documents.

Kurt Douglas Griggs. Photo courtesy of Montgomery County Jail

icon to expand image

Griggs was ordered to be committed to Summit Behavioral Healthcare in Cincinnati for treatment, with reports on his treatment to be sent to the court within six months of his commitment. A hearing on the matter was set for July 22.

At the time of writing, Griggs was in the Montgomery County Jail.

He was initially charged for breaking into and severely damaging property at the former church at 3680 Wagner Ford Road.

The property, which was dubbed Castle Morningstar by the owners, had been converted into two apartments and a photography studio, and is surrounded by Willow View Cemetery.

According to a Vandalia Municipal Court affidavit, Montgomery County Sheriff’s Deputies responded to the property at 7:30 a.m. on Feb. 29 for a report of a man throwing rocks or bricks at the windows.

Security camera footage at the property showed that Griggs had been there since 3 a.m., a sheriff’s office report said.

The residents were not home at the time of the break-in.

Griggs was found inside the building, and admitted to deputies that he had caused the damage, the affidavit said.

Damage was extensive – multiple windows were broken, including an antique stained glass window, as well as equipment, furniture and other property. Small decorative items were thrown onto the lawn, and a car in the parking lot had both windshields and all of its windows smashed.

According to the sheriff’s report, Griggs said that he broke into the building because he heard a woman screaming inside, and destroyed the items when he didn’t find anyone inside.

This is not the first time Griggs was charged for an incident near the property. In October 2023, Griggs pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor desecration charge involving the Willow View Cemetery.

He was sentenced to 90 days in jail with credit for 12 days and 78 days suspended and one year of non-reporting probation. He was also ordered to stay away from the cemetery, to complete outpatient treatment and commit no further crimes, according to court documents.

About the Author