Grand jury declines to indict woman on Miami County voter fraud allegation

In other cases, county didn’t pursue prosecution, saying first-time voter made innocent mistake, other voter had no criminal intent
Voters sign in to vote Tuesday, November 7, 2023, at the St. John the Baptist Catholic Church in Tipp City. MARSHALL GORBY \STAFF

Voters sign in to vote Tuesday, November 7, 2023, at the St. John the Baptist Catholic Church in Tipp City. MARSHALL GORBY \STAFF

TROY — Criminal charges will not be filed against three people accused of possible voter fraud in Miami County, including a former Troy woman who wrote on social media that she returned to Troy in November to vote for new schools even though she now lives in Vandalia.

The Miami County Board of Elections in November agreed to send to the county prosecutors’ office ballots of four voters for review of possible fraud. Following the board discussion, one of the four ballots was not forwarded to prosecutors because the office received further information explaining that only one ballot was cast by the person involved, said Laura Bruns, county elections director.

Prosecutors determined there was no criminal intent to pursue action against one who voted twice, first in early voting and again on Election Day.

Another individual who was not registered asked to vote Election Day. She was given a provisional ballot, filled it out and then ran the ballot through the ballot scanner instead of returning it to a poll worker for processing, Bruns said. This was the person’s first time voting, she said.

County Prosecutor Tony Kendell said he and his investigator agreed those were “innocent and silly mistakes.” This is similar to what prosecutors have tended to find in the vast majority of cases when they have been asked to explore possible voter fraud.

In the former Troy resident case, Bruns told the elections board information in the incident was presented to a county grand jury. The grand jury voted to return a no bill, meaning no charge.

Kendell said he could not discuss this case because of the confidentiality of grand jury proceedings.

That incident of possible voter fraud was brought to the attention of election officials after a woman posted a message on social media describing how she had voted in the Troy election instead of where she now lives.

“I recently moved to Vandalia (planning to move back eventually), but I am still registered to vote in Troy,” the woman wrote. “I’m glad I was able to vote on your school levy over Vandalia’s as Troy needed it more.”

Another participant on the social media site asked if the woman had voted to raise Troy’s school taxes, even though she doesn’t live in Troy.

“Yes. However, I work and do all of my shopping in Troy. My daughter went to Troy City Schools for three years. They needed the funding badly. We plan to move back to Troy in the next three years,” the voter answered.

Another case referred to prosecutors after the initial referrals remains under investigation, Bruns said. That situation involved a person who registered and voted absentee by mail in Miami County, then on Election Day voted provisional in Athens County.

Contact this contributing writer at nancykburr@aol.com

About the Author