Trotwood: Page edges McDonald in mayor race; two other incumbents also lose

Denise Moore and Rhonda Finley topped Trotwood city council race; Lumpkin, Simmons win schools race
Andrea Heeley votes Tuesday, November 7, 2023 at the St. John the Baptist Catholic Church in Tipp City. MARSHALL GORBY \STAFF

Andrea Heeley votes Tuesday, November 7, 2023 at the St. John the Baptist Catholic Church in Tipp City. MARSHALL GORBY \STAFF

Residents in Trotwood appear to have elected mayoral challenger Yvette Page over incumbent Mary McDonald in a close race, according to final, unofficial results from the Montgomery County Board of Elections.

With 18 of 18 precincts reporting, voters favored Page by a 50.99% to 49.01% ratio.

Running for her third term as mayor of Trotwood, incumbent McDonald faced off against Page, who is the city’s vice mayor. Both Page and McDonald are Democrats. This is round two of McDonald v. Page for Trotwood’s top seat, as the two ran against each other in 2019, with Page losing by a very slim margin.

McDonald has served on Trotwood City Council since 2005 and was first voted mayor in 2019, winning against incumbent Joyce Sutton Cameron. Page was first elected to council in 2017 against incumbent Rap Hankins, representing Trotwood’s second ward. She was appointed vice mayor in 2022.

Trotwood City Council

Trotwood voters also selected candidates to fill two city council seats. With 18 of 18 precincts reporting, final unofficial results show current school board member Denise Moore and incumbent city council member Rhonda Finley winning, with Moore receiving 31% of votes and Finley having received 25%.

Incumbent Robert Kelley Jr. received 23% of votes and Norman Scearce – a pastor who formerly served on Trotwood’s school board – received 21%.

Trotwood school board

Voters in Trotwood also decided two seats for Trotwood-Madison school board. With 22 of 22 precincts reporting, Aaron Lumpkin and Dionne Simmons were far ahead, with 44% and 41% of votes, respectively. Incumbent Craig Anderson received 15% of the votes.

About the Author