Miami County woman guilty of embezzling $124K from American Legion post

Mary Branham had been keeping the Piqua post’s books for years, says she has a gambling addiction.
Miami County Courthouse

Miami County Courthouse

TROY – A Bethel Twp. woman who said she has a gambling addiction pleaded guilty Thursday to felony theft for embezzling more than $124,000 from the Piqua American Legion Post 184.

Mary A. Branham, 46, was accused of theft from the post’s bank accounts between Jan. 1, 2017, and Oct. 11, 2020.

A Piqua police report said money was taken from several accounts at the post, with post leaders alerted to issues with the accounts in October 2020 by a representative of their bank in Piqua.

Branham had been keeping the books for the American Legion post for five years prior to the discovery of the thefts, police were told.

Defense lawyer Bradley Anderson said Branham has a gambling addiction and has been getting treatment. She has paid back $32,000, with $92,426 remaining to be paid, according to comments made during her hearing.

A police detective said Branham told him she was taking money to play Keno while she was working. “If she did not have enough money to cover her losses at the end of the night, she admitted she would (short) the deposits,” the detective wrote.

Branham pleaded to theft Thursday in Miami County Common Pleas Court after her application to participate in an In Lieu of Conviction, or ILC, program was denied by Judge Jeannine Pratt.

In the ILC program, a person can have the charge against them dismissed if they complete conditions of a court agreement.

Placing Branham in an ICL program would demean the seriousness of her crime, said Paul Watkins, first assistant county prosecutor.

Pratt said she had reviewed a mental health assessment and treatment plan for Branham. She ruled Branham was not eligible for ILC because of the nature of the crime, the victims being a veterans’ service organization, Branham holding a position of trust and that some of the funds stolen had been provided by area foundations for repairs to the Legion facilities.

“I want to get this behind me. I am ready to get them paid back, and move forward,” Branham told the judge.

Representatives of the American Legion post attended the Thursday hearing but made no comments.

Branham could receive up to 18 months in prison or up to five years of community control when she is sentenced April 25.

About the Author