The 32-year-old’s first conviction in 2009 was overturned by juror misconduct, a second jury was hung in 2010, and a third jury convicted him in 2011.
Berry-Godsey filed two petitions with the high court. Her first appeal asked the justices two questions: whether the bathtub was illegally ripped out of the couple’s home and whether “junk science” testimony about hand and forearm prints on the now infamous tub should have been allowed.
The high court denied the petition Oct. 7 without comment.